Interview One: Disability Advocacy Community
Raw Notes
Participant details have been generalized and all names removed to protect participant privacy. Quotes are preserved except where they contained identifying information.
1) Tell me something about your background, including your cultural background, your academic background, things you believe, and your health background.
I am an undergraduate student in the humanities.
I’m interested in advocacy and consider myself as an activist.
I’ve been a disability advocate for several years, and have done a lot of things around transition care (from nursing home back to the community). I also do research on how family units contribute to perceptions to disabled among disability community and ableism. I also work as a mentor for disabled younger teenagers.
I live with a physical disability that impacts mobility and fine motor skills such as typing. I get tired more quickly as a result. Because the condition is usually framed as a childhood disorder, there is a lack of resources for adults. This gap got me into activism. Social platforms are the first place where adults start to share about these resources like diagnosis, hacks to get around the disability, etc.
2) Now let’s talk about your journey with Twitter. Tell me about how long you’ve used it, why did you start using it, and anything else you’d like me to know.
I started using it very recently, July 2021. A mentor recommended it to me, as a means to connect with other people. He told me that a lot of jobs and opportunities for disabled people are posted on Twitter.
I tweet mostly about my experience on campus and outside of it to raise awareness. Apparently this is eye-opening for a lot of people, because they get to offer different perspectives that were unheard, so I communicate what I know to other people. COVID pandemic makes people struggle with communication. Specifically, in the disabled community, there are so many things that sweep disabled people, so I push for our rights on Twitter too.
Social Media helps me find community and a way to out reach people.
I am also careful with what I do or don’t post. For example, I don’t post about my specific conditions, and I’m cautious about what I post. I want to point issues that disabled people may have share, without having to reveal too much about myself. Sometimes I take posts down if others retweet me on things I don’t want to be retweeted.
3) Wow, it seems you know a lot about Twitter. That’s great. Could you let me know some things you like or didn’t like about Twitter?
I like Twitter’s open communication. If you want to talk to another disabled person, you can just search them up. There are also other disability-related hash tags that people use, such as #AnyISvoid and #DisCo. Through these hashtags you can find community and share resources like how to advocate for yourself when you go to a doctor’s. Certain people put things in their bio, like wheelchair emoji or follow mutual friends on Twitter. When I reach out, it’s very helpful. Online viral community very important and helpful, because a lot of times disabled people don’t have the bandwidth to necessarily join others in person. For example, as a disabled person from a religious minority, I can find that community online. I like how Twitter is useful inherently, and you can give guidance and receive guidance
There are many things I don’t like about Twitter. If your replied to someone, you get a notification on Twitter, but I don’t see it as something that you should get notification on. It’s disruptive. Also privacy. Sometimes you don’t want people to get a hold of your account. Twitter Circle kind of fixes the privacy issue, but it can be restricted. Besides, there’s always the danger over where your public posts end up. It could end up in a dark place. It’s also hard to keep track of long threads. Other issues with Twitter include not very much fact checking. Someone can post one thing, and someone can post another thing, and you don’t know who’s right. There’s also hate speech. Recently on Queen Elizabeth II, there’s hate speech regarding her complicated legacy on Twitter. People also like to take things out of context. Also the way Twitter’s algorithm works does not tell you whether things are bad engagement or good engagement. As long as you quote tweets, it signifies that things deserve more attention. But what about bad things?
The lack of privacy is concerning. Someone I know was harassed in person after an article about them went viral at their school. They don’t even use social media, but it still dragged them into it. Broadcasting can lead to physical harassment. People who are not online are not those who are spreading the rumors. There isn’t nearly enough done about cyber information and how to safeguard personal information for people who are not online. There’s also misinformation. When bombing threats happened in Boston Children’s Hospital through Twitter, people took down doctor’s information for safety reasons. Patients who are searching for a doctor now have a more difficult time.
4) So throughout the time you’ve used Twitter, what are some of the ways you have seen Twitter evolve?
Twitter has changed a lot to be accessible. There is now alt text that you can use to describe image.
Also it’s funny how entities roast each other. For example, when McDonald tweeted “we have better burgers than Burger King”, Burger King fought back by saying “we are BURGER KING”. Tweets became used for interaction between different entities instead of just being informative. It’s like internet’s version of “oh burn”.
5) Twitter has grown in popularity indeed. Have you ever interacted with Twitter in another language? What's that experience like?
Yes, there are issues with translation. For example, I read a second language, and can see that translation is not accurate. In the same way, ASL on Twitter is also not accurate. Certain words are censored in captions for ASL but not the hearing version, and this can cause people who struggle with hearing to be confused.
6) If you have to choose, what is Twitter's biggest value to you? What are some ways that Twitter make you feel unformatable, if any?
On face value, Twitter’s greatest value to me is being able to categorize different communities. It likes recommending things/groups that are similar to you. It has that community aspect that I like.
A lot of times people tend to put censor warnings on posts from or with disabled people. I wish there’s more transparency on what they choose to hide. For example, bombings are not censored, but people on a wheel chair is. People’s versions of obscene content might vary. I wish there’s more clarity, or at least more labeling.
I’m concerned also about protests. People are very easily recognizable in these video, and it can lead to consequences such as the participant getting fired from work because of it. There’s also no way to appeal it. Twitter doesn’t protect people’s privacy. In Europe’s Twitter, there’s a lot checks available, like checking boxes to give consents. I wish there are better privacy laws.
7) Is there anything else that you would like me to know?
One thing I worry about as a disabled person is having my name displayed on the screen. It’s a good thing when people know me, but it also lead to being part of the internet that I don’t want to be on. For example, once my email got leaked and it was very stressful.
Report
I am surprised that Twitter is a place, especially for physically disabled people, to find their community. I’ve always seen Twitter as a place to feed in on news, or related to getting updates from others. When Participant A said “If you want to talk to another disabled person, you can just search them up. There are also other disability-related hash tags that people use, such as #AnyISvoid and #DisCo. Through these hashtags you can find community and share resources like how to advocate for yourself when you go to a doctor’s. Certain people put things in their bio, like wheelchair emoji or follow mutual friends on Twitter. When I reach out, it’s very helpful. Online viral community very important and helpful, because a lot of times disabled people don’t have the bandwidth to necessarily join others in person”, that was very insightful. I begin to understand that one of Twitter’s most valuable feature (including its hashtag), is that it actually fosters and brings together people search for a community. The social aspect of Twitter is definitely something I want to extend to Fritter, along with its informative side. The hashtag and profiles are not there for convention; they are there for a purpose. Including them may help others find the resources they need or the community they have hoped for. Therefore, I start to appreciate Twitter’s measures of letting people find each other easily. However, easy socializing meant there is a potential comprise over privacy. I was shocked how online presence could affect indirect stakeholders who are offline. Specifically, when Participant A told me that her friend “got harassed in person” because “an article about him went viral in his school” and “he doesn’t even use social media, but it still dragged him into it”. With how fast information is spreading on Twitter, there needs to be measures to ensure anonymity and physical safety of all direct and indirect members. When users have to “take posts down if others retweet [them] on things [they] don’t want to be retweeted” or “take down [personal] information”, it indicates that concerns over privacy are getting too loud.
Another good point to consider as a developer is transparency, especially when it comes to algorithms that directly affect users’ feed. Like Participant A said, Twitter’s algorithm does not “tell you whether things are bad engagement or good engagement”. Every single interaction boosts up the post. Without considering user’s feelings towards a certain post, this algorithm could both create an echo chamber or aggravate further division online. In essence, this could lead to polarization and people getting worked up over certain controversial topics. Issues such as “hate speech” would then ensue. There needs to be measures for user input when it comes to their feed, and also some degree of control while ensuring freedom of expression.
Synthesis
In summary, Twitter’s values lie greatly in its open community. Through hashtags and profile bios, people are able to find resources they are looking whether, whether it’s a group that they identify with, a posting they want to read, or an update they hope to receive. With this publicity comes to concern over privacy. Specifically, we want to be able to find a balance between easy socializing and privacy. In Fritter, we would thus want to ensure that we both foster an open community and also protect users’ community. This means we want to incorporate features that allow users to interact with each other, while also seeking measures that protect the users’ personal information. Some of the features I’m thinking about are DM’s, post and comment, sharing, and some visual elements like FB story or gag reels.
Another important point is transparent algorithm. When generating curated content for the user, we want to make sure that it’s something the user actually likes. On the other hand, we also want to make sure that it does not create an eco chamber. Once in awhile, it’s nice to offer a different (yet fact-checked) perspective. A concept we could explore is user input, where they can periodically provide feedback on what they like and we update the algorithm using their input. In Fritter, we could ask users to periodically fill out a survey, which include questions about their interests and about what they would like to see on their feed. Then we can generate new content using these feedback forms.