Interview Two: High-Frequency News and Politics Reader

Raw Notes

Participant details have been generalized and all names removed to protect participant privacy. Quotes are preserved except where they contained identifying information.

1) Tell me something about your background, including your cultural background, your academic background, things you believe, and your health background.

  • I’m currently an undergraduate studying computer science. I follow politics closely and hold strong views.

  • 2) Now let’s talk about your journey with Twitter. Tell me about how long you’ve used it, why did you start using it, and anything else you’d like me to know.

  • I probably use Twitter way too much. I really like Twitter.
  • I started using Twitter sophomore or junior year of high school. I got Twitter because a close friend used it, so we can read funny tweets together and find out more about each other. Now I probably use it more than they do.
  • I think Twitter is a good way or at least a quick way to find out about news and new events. For example, I’m interested in basketball, and I can quickly find events related to basketball. Also news about video games and new show too.
  • I’m also very interested in politics. I can find out about major news on Twitter. It gives an indicator of how people feel about something. I mostly lurk on Twitter and browse more than I post.
  • I can also connect with friends on Twitter.

  • 3) Wow, it seems you know a lot about Twitter. That’s great. Could you let me know some things you like or didn’t like about Twitter?

  • I like how it’s quick. You can find information quickly. If you are not interested in something, it’s also really easy to scroll by.
  • I don’t like how addicting it is. I can get into the habit of scrolling, and spend too much time. I wish there's like a built-in screen time, like how Apple products do. Twitter could do a better job of filtering things you want to see and don’t want to see. There could have some sort of adjusting in Twitter setting. For example, Google ads has the feature to click on “not interested”. I wish there’s more user choice for what’s popping up, like you can indicate what you want to see more and what you don’t want to see as much. It would be nice if user has input to a curated content, not just the algorithm.

  • 4) So throughout the time you’ve used Twitter, what are some of the ways you have seen Twitter evolve?

  • People can get access to information really easily and really quickly. But there’s now also more echo chamber going on. Like if you lean one way directly, you are probably going to interact with only people sharing the same mindset. It’s so Polarizing. People are less open to other ideas now. Otherwise, I don’t think too much has changed. Changes that happen are your own interest.
  • People like Trump also use Twitter as a political campaign. Celebrities are also tweeting. I feel like maybe in the future, we can engage with celebrities. Twitter would be a good way to directly engage with celebrities.

  • 5) Twitter has grown in popularity indeed. Have you ever interacted with Twitter in another language? What's that experience like?

  • I have family ties to another country, so I follow an account that posts everyday scenes from there. It has funny pictures and offers the perspective from another country. It’s cool to get perspective of another country. Like it shows you things you wouldn’t see in a travel brochure.

  • 6) If you have to choose, what is Twitter's biggest value to you? What are some ways that Twitter make you feel unconfortable, if any?

  • I like getting information quickly from Twitter.
  • Twitter is a forum for people to say what they think. There’s freedom of expression.
  • I’m worried about buzzword. I’m also worried about security. Like how some accounts could be bot. I wish there’s universal Access. Right now you need an account to access Twitter, but I feel like there shouldn’t be that need if you are just browsing. If you are interacting with others, there there should be measures to make sure it’s a real person.
  • I’m also concerned about there being an echo chamber. I feel like people gravitate towards groups they already associate with, and Twitter keeps on sending them content they like.

  • 7) Is there anything else that you would like me to know?

  • Sometimes there could be tensions on Twitter, and that drives people away. As much as I think freedom of expression is important, there should less of an echo chamber.

  • Report

    It is surprising to see Participant B consider Twitter as an easy and quick way to get information. When he mentions “I think Twitter is a good way or at least a quick way to find out about news and new events”, it was very insightful. Out of the many things people said about Twitter, a lot tend to focus on Twitter’s misinformation and how packed/overwhelming one’s feed can get. Thus, being able to see Twitter as an accessible news channel is a very important perspective I’ve gained through the interview. This fast information and therefore instant gratification tend to make people addicted to Twitter. Participant B mentions how he “can get into the habit of scrolling”, and thus “spend too much time”. A suggestion he has is to incorporate “a built-in screen time”, similar to the screen limit in Apple products. I find this very insightful too. It gets me to think about not just users’ transition and ease of use when they log onto Twitter/first create an account, but also the intention to help users’ off boarding when they log off/need a break.

    A slight contradiction here involves “if you are not interested in something, it’s also really easy to scroll by” v.s. “Twitter keeps on sending [people] content they like”. It seems that Twitter makes it difficult to see content you don’t necessarily like. In other words, if you “lean one way directly”, you are “probably going to interact with only people sharing the same mindset”. Twitter can at times be polarizing, and creates “an echo chamber”. At the same time, it seems like Twitter’s algorithm does not completely lean towards user’s interests, such that they still need to scroll by things they don’t like. Either way, from this interview, we do see a lack of user input when it comes to a user’s curated feed. Participant B wishes “there’s more user choice for what’s popping up, like you can indicate what you want to see more and what you don’t want to see as much”. Similar to Participant A, Participant B thinks “it would be nice if user has input to a curated content, not just the algorithm”. Some of of participatory design would be valuable here.


    Synthesis

    In summary, a big part of Twitter’s value lies in its fast and instantaneous communicate. Through the character limit and hashtags, people are able to quick access information they are interested in or want to see. With such speediness comes the need of balance. An important aspect when it comes to designing Fritter is therefore to ensure that users are able to find what they need in a timely manner, while also able to have to capacity to exit the app. This means we want to establish a search functionality which allows users to find what they need quickly. To prevent addiction, we also need to set in place measures such as screen time limit or scrolling limit. A reference is that in Duolingo and some game apps, there are gems you could collect. Once the gems run out, it’s time to put down the app. We could borrow something similar when designing Fritter. Another way to go about this is to borrow Apple’s screen time limit and apply that onto Fritter, so the app locks when screen time limit hits (with, of course, a few minutes of flexibility in case the user needs to finish up important tasks).

    Anther important need here is user input. Similar to being transparent, we again want users to be able to have some control over what they are seeing. Instead of relying purely on computer’s algorithm and risk creating an echo chamber, we could leave the choice up to the user in Fritter. An idea is to send out periodically surveys, where the user could tell us about what type of content they hope to see more. A question to include is whether one wants to see a different perspective related to a particular topic that one is interested in. If the answer is yes, then we can provide more perspectives from other users who don’t share the same opinion. Overall, no matter what design we choose to go with (i.e. survey, algorithm, and/or hashtags), it’s important to include user’s direct and explicit feedback. This not only fosters transparency but also improves usability by periodically examining user’s (constant-changing) needs if necessary.