Part 1: Peer Review
Peer Reviewer A
Compliments
I like the idea of having an anonymous page and at the same time the option of a verified account. I think the synchronization between account creation and community verification really helps establish both the social and private aspect of your app. (Concept Synchronization)
I also think employing discourse is pretty helpful in Fritter, considering how there are multiple echo chambers created in Twitter. I think you conveyed discourse’s efficacy — from purpose to state to action — pretty well. Keep up the good work! (Concept Efficacy)
Overall, I like the simplicity of your design, especially of your concept Feed. It is similar to Twitter’s original design, and thus allows users to more easily transition from Twitter to Fritter. Good job! (Concept Simplicity)
Criticisms
I wish to see more explanation for the concept “page anonymity”. You mentioned in your pitch that users can choose to remain anonymous and use page instead of personal account. I find this very interesting and hope to see what this page entails. Specifically, what are the states and supported actions? If you could elaborate, wireframe, or even make it an independent concept of its own, that would be great! Right now, it looks merged into the Account Creation Concept, which only covers personal account. (Concept Independence)
I hope to see more of the Freet concept, with details on what actions handle which use cases. From what I’m seeing, it looks like Freet is pretty similar to original Tweet concept. This is intuitive (which by the way is great), but I’m unsure of exactly what Freet does. What is the difference between a tweet and a freet? (Concept Efficacy)
I’m a bit worried about the Community Verification concept. Specifically, I’m concerned about the cost of time. How long does it take for an account to be approved? Will this be a long and time consuming process? (Concept Simplicity)
Speculations
I wonder how the concept Discourses is processed for each Club. Specifically, how often are the polls created? How often do they change? (Concept Efficacy)
I’m curious to see how Freets and Discourses can be synced in any way. For example, after choosing a topic for a poll, can user post for that topic? (Concept Synchronization)
I’m interested in how Account Creation concept takes place. How does the verification work, and how does Fritter check for valid ID (i.e. suppose a user uploads fake information)? (Concept Efficacy)
Peer Reviewer B
Compliments
I like the idea of having Purchase concept when users browse through the Freets. I think the synchronization between Purchase concept and Freets concept could be really helpful for users who see recommendations on Fritter. They no longer have to exit the app and search for products. Good job! (Concept Synchronization)
I think employing View Only concept in Fritter is a brilliant idea! On one hand, you’ve tighten the Reaction concept with the Freet concept, allowing sharing of information directly under a post. On the other hand, you’ve loosed such connection to allow the author the choice. I could see how it’s beneficial when opinions might be controversial; it helps reduce conflict. (Concept Synchronization)
I love how simple the Purchase concept is. It very much models how a shopping cart works in platforms like Amazon, and thus allow users to adapt pretty quickly. Well done! (Concept Simplicity)
Criticisms
I wish to see more diversity in terms of the React concept. The few default emojis might not be able to capture the user’s emotions. It would be really nice to see more emojis. For example, adding more emoji from the user’s key boards would better support the purpose of the React concept. (Concept Efficacy)
I am concerned about the relationship between View Only concept and Account concept. Specifically, suppose a user only wants to keep certain feeds only while others interactive, one is unable to do so. Seeking a middle ground between closing reactions and allowing interaction would be nice. (Concept Independence)
I would love to see if there is any verification ensuring the valid identity of a merchant. Suppose a user chooses to buy something on Twitter, how will one know if merchant is not a bot? I think perhaps syncing Purchase concept with a new Verification concept would help. (Concept Synchronization)
Speculations
I’m curious to see how MFA concept affects accessibility. What if the user does not have working data to support such authentication? I think the cost of such authentication can be considered. (Concept Simplicity)
I wonder how will reviews be posted if a seller account choose turn off comments. How will users know what other users think about such product?
I’m interested in how Purchase concept’s transaction takes place. How does the payment and shipping work? How would users tracking the progress and shipment? How do sellers keep track of their orders? What states are available to support the above actions on the seller’s side? (Concept Efficacy)
Joshua Mbogo
I'm unable to provide a peer review for Joshua, because he does not have A1 or A3 posted on his website.
His A2 doesn't not contain any photo, so I'm unsure of what to evaluate. I've reached out to him via email
but did not recieve a response. I've also reached out to the course staff via email and talked to Professor Arvind
after class to explain about the situation.
Part 2: Self Review
Criticisms
(Concept Synchronization) Similar to Peer Reviewer A and Peer Reviewer C’s concern, I am also looking for ways to improve the synchronization between Fritter_Chat and Fritter_Reward. On one hand, I want to foster social interaction through chat (thus using reward as an incentive). On the other hand, I want to prevent spamming. The current design and sync rules make it easy for two friends to spam one another as a means to circumvent the reward system. To address this middle ground, see “Better Syncing Fritter_Chat and Fritter_Reward” in Modifications
(Concept Independence) Peer Reviewer A brought up a really good point where Fritter_Chat and Fritter_Time_Limit might be in conflict with each other, or at least affect each other in some way. A scenario is that if Fritter’s time limit is up, users are unable to continue their conversation. To address this issue, see “Better Independence between Fritter_Chat and Fritter_Time_Limit” in Modifications .
(Concept Efficacy) Peer Reviewer D and Peer Reviewer C both said that they don’t see how Fritter_Friend works. I realize that I didn’t really explain how Fritter_Friend works, because I didn’t really tie in the “friend” concept with the “follower” concept with clarity. For now, it seems as if Fritter_Friend only exists to make Fritter_Reward happen. Peer Reviewer D also suggested that Fritter_Friend can be synced with Fritter_Reward too. To address these things, see “Better Explanation of Fritter_Friend and Fritter_Reward” in Modifications.
(Concept Simplicity) Peer Reviewer D and Peer Reviewer C both brought up the cost of operation for Fritter_Survey. It could be tedious for the user to fill out a survey everyday. Thus, to address this issue and reduce such cost of operation for the user, see “Better Operation for Fritter_Survey” in Modifications.
Speculation
There has been some speculations about public post. Peer Reviewer A and Peer Reviewer C both mentioned that it might discourage people from posting or induce anxiety. However, the reason I choose to make all posts public is to foster public interaction. Just like some people will choose to post on Instagram or Facebook, they too will choose to post on Fritter. While some people are less comfortable, they can just view other people’s posts and use the chat function on Fritter. The goal isn’t for everyone to post; it is to foster social interactions.
Part 3: Modifications
Better Syncing Fritter_Chat and Fritter_Reward
To prevent spam, I will change the app such that it includes a “grammar check”. This mainly checks for whether messages sent out by one user to others are similar. Spam messages generally follow pretty similar format, such as a string of letters with no particular meaning, a single letter, etc. A way of implementing this could be connecting the web app to a dictionary API and checks to see if words exist.
Better Independence between Fritter_Chat and Fritter_Time_Limit
To prevent user from being cut off mid-conversation due to time limit, I will add another option that says “Use Chat Only”. Thus, others are able to continue checking. The time limit will then only apply to browsing public post.
Better Explanation of Fritter_Friend and Fritter_Reward
Adding another user on Fritter doesn’t just allow DM. It also ensures that regardless of what the user fills out in the survey, he/she can always see a friend’s post in his/her feed. I will also integrate another feature in Fritter Reward System: whenever a user comment under a friend’s post, it adds 10 points. This way, it encourages interaction between friends. To view a friend’s post, we don’t need to use any additional point. However, this is a one way system. Following a user does not mean adding a user as a friend, while adding a user as a friend means being able to follow him/her without needing more points to unlock his/her posts.
Better Operation for Fritter_Survey
In order to maintain content transparency and lower cost of operation, I will allow user to use yesterday’s survey answer. This way, user knows why certain posts are popping up and don’t have to fill the survey daily if they don’t want to. I will also make hashtags mandatory when a user posts. This way, these posts don’t just show up on their friends’ feed, but also allow for more public sharing.